What if the US removes Hong Kong’s special status?

PompeoPicture copyright
Getty Photographs

Prime members of the US administration have warned that Hong Kong now not deserves a particular standing when it comes commerce, and the territory might be handled the identical means as mainland China.

Till now, the US has given Hong Kong beneficial buying and selling phrases, courting again to the territory’s time as a British colony, however US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo informed Congress that Hong Kong now not enjoys a excessive diploma of autonomy from China

In the meantime, President Donald Trump’s prime financial adviser Larry Kudlow mentioned Beijing “will likely be held accountable” for a brand new safety legislation set to be imposed on Hong Kong.

The Nationwide Financial Council Director informed CNBC, “If want be, Hong Kong now could need to be handled the identical means as China is handled, and that has implications for tariffs”.

So what is going to it imply if that particular standing is revoked?

Hong Kong is well-known as one of many world’s most necessary monetary centres. With a free economic system and a aggressive tax regime, it is attracted many multinational corporations to its shores.

It is also an necessary hub for commerce. However all of that might be in jeopardy, if the US modifications the best way it offers with Hong Kong.

So what’s the US threatening?

In the meanwhile, Hong Kong enjoys particular commerce relations with the US. It operates as a separate customs territory to mainland China. It additionally has a free port, which means no tariffs are charged on the import or export of products.

These preparations have helped Hong Kong turn into a centre for international commerce. However now the US is threatening to deal with Hong Kong the identical as mainland China. That will imply its items can be topic to further tariffs, together with these additional fees that had been launched as a part of the US-China commerce conflict, though a few of these have not too long ago been rolled again.

Picture copyright
Getty Photographs

“Hong Kong has had a particular buying and selling relationship with several types of tariffs and laws which have allowed it to commerce in a freer means, significantly in relation to capital markets,” mentioned Dr Rebecca Harding, unbiased commerce skilled and CEO of Coriolis Applied sciences.

“The US has handled it as an ally, in case you like. However it’s now saying we’re going to deal with you in an identical option to how we deal with China,” she mentioned.

The place does that go away Hong Kong?

Hong Kong is likely one of the world’s prime buying and selling territories. In 2018 it was ranked with the seventh highest quantity of commerce with a complete worth of almost $1.2tn.

However a lot of that commerce is made up of products that cross into, or come out of, mainland China.

In 2018, 8% of mainland China’s exports to the US and 6% of mainland China’s imports from the US, handed by way of Hong Kong.

This position as a gateway between the Chinese language market and the remainder of the world has put Hong Kong in a novel place, however totally different commerce preparations may change that.

Picture copyright
Getty Photographs

“If there is a new commerce regime in place, that modifications the calculation for corporations,” mentioned Dr Tim Summers, a Senior Fellow at Chatham Home, based mostly in Hong Kong.

Corporations may select to maneuver their items immediately by way of ports in mainland China as a substitute, and better tariffs there’ll imply increased worth tags.

“The people who find themselves going to get damage are companies and shoppers,” Dr Summers mentioned.

Will China be frightened?

Not a lot because it might need been on the time of the Hong Kong handover. Again in 1997, Hong Kong performed a way more important position in China’s economic system, accounting for round 18% of China’s GDP.

“However over the past 25 years China has grown massively,” mentioned Dr Summers. Hong Kong now contributes simply 2-3% of China’s GDP.

“Put that in context of the ocean of commerce popping out of China, it isn’t so important any extra. So if President Trump had been to behave on commerce, Hong Kong would endure, nevertheless it’s not a gamechanger for China,” he mentioned.

Picture copyright
Getty Photographs

Beijing will nevertheless need to preserve Hong Kong’s standing as a worldwide monetary centre. Mainland Chinese language corporations are amongst these which select to listing on Hong Kong’s Inventory Trade due to its entry to international capital. Mainland Chinese language corporations additionally profit from Hong Kong’s massive monetary companies sector.

“Shanghai and Shenzhen have already got a vibrant monetary companies sector serving mainlanders,” says David Webb, a former funding banker who’s lived in Hong Kong since 1991. However as long as Beijing has capital controls on the motion of cash out and in of China for funding, “then it may’t compete with Hong Kong on worldwide capital,” he mentioned.

How may this have an effect on the US?

Annually, billions of {dollars} price of products and companies are traded between Hong Kong and the US. In 2018, the full worth of that commerce was nearly $67bn in accordance with the US Commerce Consultant, together with $17bn price of imports that Individuals purchased from Hong Kong.

If Hong Kong faces the identical buying and selling phrases as mainland China, US shoppers can pay extra for these items.

“American companies each within the US itself and in Hong Kong are lobbying laborious to attempt to get any motion diluted,” mentioned Rachel Cartland, director of Cartland Consulting and a former Hong Kong civil servant.

The US Chamber of Commerce has warned that far-reaching modifications to Hong Kong’s standing would have “critical implications” for Hong Kong and US companies.

That places Washington in a difficult place, in accordance Dr Summers.

He says ostensibly, Secretary Pompeo’s menace seems to be about latest developments in Hong Kong, and Beijing’s new safety legislation for the territory. However he mentioned, what it is actually about is US-China relations.

“If I had been going to be actually cynical, I’d say this has supplied a possibility for some folks in Washington to take measures they wished to take anyway in opposition to China, within the context of a wider US-China rivalry,” he mentioned.

“That will nicely drive the pondering of what Trump does subsequent greater than any explicit concern concerning the political autonomy of Hong Kong,” he mentioned.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *



Check Also

Q&A: UN’s Agnes Callamard on drone strike that killed Soleimani | News

The United Nations’s particular rapporteur on extrajudicial, abstract and arbitrary killings introduced a brand new report ...